Two Generations, Two Speeds of Loyalty
Millennials and Generation Z are key drivers of sales for brands, but they have very different views on loyalty programs, particularly when it comes to redeeming rewards. Millennials can "work" for a benefit, but Gen Z expects immediate results, even if the reward is smaller.
Companies seeking to grow and defend themselves against competition can no longer design programs for just one generation. A hybrid program is increasingly becoming the best solution. It combines the long-term value proposition of millennials with the immediate benefits demanded by Gen Z.
How Millennials and Gen Z Buy?
Millennials (Generation Y) grew up in a world of loyalty cards, coupons, and point-based programs in retail, services, and e-commerce. They are accustomed to loyalty "paying off" over time. They receive discounts for regular purchases, larger one-time discounts, or access to higher program tiers. They value stability and predictable rewards: clear thresholds, transparent rewards tables, and real savings.
Generation Z entered adulthood in an environment of e-commerce, mobile apps, and social commerce, where everything happens in real time. They were raised with the "click and go" model of instant access to content, free trials, coupons, and flash sales. For this generation, a loyalty program that requires a long wait for a reward often loses out to an attractive one-time promotion or event sale. Many young people would rather "hunt" for deals than accumulate points for months.
Key Differences
The greatest contrast between Millennials and Gen Z is the amount of time they expect between action and reward.
- Millennials are patient and willing to wait. They can accumulate points for several months if the final reward is substantial. They desire large discounts, attractive vouchers, free shipping for a specified period, or higher status.
- Gen Z, on the other hand, is focused on the present. They expect immediate results, such as a discount on the same transaction, a free bonus, quick cash back, or immediate access to content or features after completing an action.
This difference influences the entire program design, from the points mechanics and communication to the app's UX and UI. A program that only rewards after a long series of purchases will naturally appeal to Millennials. However, it may remain almost invisible to Gen Z because it doesn't offer a "reward in a moment."
Besides time, tolerance for the complexity of redeeming a reward varies greatly.
- Millennials prefer simple rules but can accept a few steps, such as entering the app, selecting a reward, and generating a code. This is all if the rules are clearly described and don't change much.
- Gen Z has a very low tolerance for friction. If redeeming a reward requires filling out forms, searching for codes in emails, or clicking through menus, their motivation plummets.
This generation expects a process like "I see the notification, I click, and I use it," ideally within a single environment, such as a brand app, website, or eWallet. Millennials also appreciate simplicity. For them, knowing that a reward is "set aside for them" and available when needed is valuable.
Millennials and Gen Z in Numbers
Data shows that both groups actively use loyalty programs, albeit in different ways. Many studies show that millennials are one of the most loyal generations. Roughly half of them report a strong attachment to certain brands, and over 80% say that joining a loyalty program has encouraged them to spend more with that brand. However, as many as 70% of millennials say they would quit a program if the rewards were not attractive enough, which underscores the importance of offering genuinely valuable benefits.
Generation Z experiments with brands more often. Over 75% of young adults admit to liking to try new brands, and nearly 60% openly say that their brand loyalty has weakened in recent years. Nevertheless, their interest in loyalty programs is growing. According to some studies, more than half of Gen Z says they participate in programs more eagerly today than a year ago. Around 65–70% choose brands that offer attractive loyalty programs or apps. The differences are particularly visible in the restaurant and quick-service restaurant (QSR) sector: over 58% of Gen Z and 48% of millennials prefer restaurants that offer loyalty programs. Such programs are one of the key factors in deciding where to eat.
There is also a clear difference in attitudes toward reward mechanics. About 78% of Millennials like standard, points-based, and cash-back programs. Among Gen Z, however, expectations of instant value dominate. Although 65% of them accept collecting points, as many as 46% name cash-back as a particularly attractive form of reward. Importantly, both groups are highly mobile. Nearly 70% of millennials and 65% of Gen Z say mobile apps are their preferred channel for using loyalty programs. This confirms that, without a convenient mobile solution, a program loses a significant portion of its potential.
Why a "points-only" program is no longer enough?
Traditional loyalty programs based solely on points were designed primarily to meet the expectations of older consumers and Millennials. In this model, Generation Z often perceives too great a distance between their actions and the benefits. This leads to low activity and early program abandonment. From a business perspective, this represents untapped potential with younger customers who will increasingly dominate the market in the coming years.
At the same time, creating separate programs for different generations is costly and complicates operations and brand communication. Consequently, companies are looking for a solution that will allow them to serve a broad, multigenerational segment with a single system. This is where the concept of a hybrid program that connects generations comes into play.
What is it?
A hybrid program combines several well-known mechanics.
- A points and/or status layer, which addresses the need for long-term value creation, more common among Millennials.
- Immediate, simple benefits are designed for Gen Z, providing quick feedback and clear benefits immediately after action.
- Subscription or paid membership elements, which provide some benefits "out of the box" (e.g., free shipping or a fixed discount).
In practice, this could be an app that offers a discount for registering, points for purchases, instant coupons for specific actions (e.g., writing a review, referring a friend, participating in a campaign), and higher status levels with additional privileges. This design allows the program to adapt to different user styles without creating multiple solutions.
How a hybrid program meets Millennial expectations.
For millennials, three things are most important: a sense of value, transparency, and predictability. A hybrid program can achieve this by offering:
- A clear points system with transparent value (e.g., X points equal a $ discount) without hidden conditions or numerous exceptions.
- Status levels (tiers) that reward consistency, such as free shipping, longer returns, and early access to promotions or product launches.
- Planning capabilities: Users can see how far they need to go to reach the next tier and make conscious purchase decisions to do so.
This layer of the program makes them feel like loyalty truly "pays off" and that their commitment translates into growing, tangible benefits.
How does a hybrid program meet Gen Z expectations?
Gen Z needs a signal of benefits almost immediately after completing an action. In a hybrid program, this can be achieved through:
- Instant rewards, such as a discount on first purchases, a free product upon registration, a discount for downloading the app, or adding a card to your eWallet.
- Event mechanics, such as scratch cards, wheels of fortune, in-app gamification, and time challenges that provide immediately visible rewards.
- Quick social missions offer points or instant coupons for participating in live events, sharing content, writing reviews, adding product photos, and more.
These features transform the program from a "dry table of benefits" into a dynamic experience that young users eagerly return to.
Business Benefits of a Hybrid Program
From a company's perspective, a hybrid program offers specific, measurable advantages:
- Broad generational reach: One cohesive system covers various generations, from Gen Z to Millennials to older customers, who also value point programs.
- Higher engagement: Instant benefits increase the engagement of younger users, while the points and status layer retain mature customers long term.
- Better competitive defense: The more deeply a program is embedded in customers' daily habits through apps, promotions, or status, the more difficult it is to persuade them to switch brands.
In 2026, when almost every major brand has a loyalty program, the advantage lies in adapting the program to the changing generational makeup of customers. A hybrid model naturally responds to this trend because it meets the expectations of both Millennials and Gen Z without rewarding either group.